Last night’s The Voice 2013 live results show was truly shocking.

sarah simmons eliminated

From left, Holly Tucker, Judith Hill and Sarah Simmons appear on “The Voice.” (Tyler Golden / NBC / May 28, 2013)

In our Small Screen Scoop poll that ran early on Tuesday, hundreds of votes said most of you thought The Swon Brothers were most likely to go home. The least likely to go home, according to you wonderful fans, was Danielle Bradbery and Michelle Chamuel. Luckily, we do still have them both. (Perhaps The Voice winner is a little less about having the best voice, and a little more about connecting emotionally and sharing a story.)

Both Judith Hill and Sarah Simmons were eliminated on The Voice last night. Both were members of Team Adam Levine, and perhaps none were more shocked than the rocker. As soon as he got the news, live, he mouthed “What?” to fellow coach, Shakira.

It’s true that many thought that both of them would be safe, and perhaps that “oh, they’ll get through” mentality contributed to no one voting for them.

As you look over the internet, you’ll see that many people seem divided on whether they thought Judith Hill was a shoe-in, or Sarah Simmons was.

We’re curious, who are you more sad to have lost? Click your choice in the poll below, and see how you measure up with everyone else’s thoughts on the matter.

Topic: Judith Hill eliminated, Sarah Simmons eliminated

Stay tuned to Small Screen Scoop for more on The Voice!