The 11 guys were judged on their interview, talent and (of course) the swimsuit competition, in front of a live audience in Atlantic City, New Jersey. Mikey T. was enthusiastic and ready to take the title, stating, “We’re all competitors, so we all want this.” However, it was Casey who was crowned “The Bachelorette’s Mr. America,” making Mikey T. and Zak W. feel they were “robbed.”

After the contest, the group