It’s that time of year: the 2011 Emmy nominations are here. As usual, SYTYCD dominated the choreography category. But this year, there was one category that FINALLY got some SYTYCD love…..
So You Think You Can Dance Emmy Nominations 2011
Before we get to the dances, I need to do a huge, full o’ love shout out to the gorgeous, Cat Deeley. She is hands down, my favorite host. She manages to both be supportive of the judges and the dancers without seeming condescending towards either. During audition rounds she shows respect to the crazies. And she is obviously well loved by every dancer – she has maintained a friendship with almost every dancer that has graced the stage in the Top 20. Oh, and she looks fan-flippin-tastic every single week. So well deserved. Be sure to give Jesse Tyler Ferguson a big hug for making it happen for you last night.
Now, on to the choreographers. This year they nominated based on a body of work, rather than one specific dance, which is not surprising given the level of so many of the dances last summer. So all of you can decide, I wanted to provide links to all of the nominated routines- I starred my favorite from each nominee.
(Technically, there is one non-SYTYCD nomination. Mark Ballas for DWTS. I think he is great, I do. But the routines on DWTS do not hold a candle to the ones on SYTYCD, even if you only compare Ballroom to Ballroom. If Mark wins, I call shenanigans
Allison Holker, The Top 6 Season 7 guys & All-Star guys
Top 8 Group Performance & All-Stars
Billy Bell, Alex Wong and Ade Obayomi
I LOVED the Alice routine. I think it was very Mia Michaels. Plus I adored that she was not afraid to make Allison the star of the guys group routine. It was creative, used the music appropriately and accentuated the strength of each performer. Tho the other two routines were classic “moving Mia Michaels,” and I loved them. But sometimes you just need some wacky Mia, you know? Plus I’m a sucker for anything with Allison.
Billy Bell & Ade Obayomi
Kent Boyd & Allison Holker
Heaven is a Place on Earth (sorry, could only find tour video of this one)
Robert Roldan & Kathryn McCormick
This was a hard one, as I do love all three, but the story of Mad World was just so haunting and Stacey managed to get such heart-wrenching performances out of both Billy and Ade. They are different kinds of dancers and yet she utilized them each perfectly creating a wonderful balance. But the other two are gorgeous, and the rehearsal footage of Kent & Allison always makes me giggle. Kent is my favorite ever and I love him in a totally non-creepy way.
Kent Boyd & Lauren Froderman
Kent Boyd & Neil Haskell
Robert Roldan & Allison Holker
I picked Fix You because I can’t hear this song without picturing every moment of this dance in my head. However, all 3 are pure genius and are in my top 5 of last season. And they rank Top 10 for all seasons, honestly. Collide was pure magic and showed how wonderful Kent and Lauren were together and apart. How it Ends was just one of several Kent/Neil routines that were amazing. Those two boys are meant to dance side by side. But Fix You…. well, it broke my heart and you just can’t compete with that.
Tabitha & Naopleon D’umo
Robert Roldan & Dominic Sandoval
Adechike Torbert & Comfort Fedoke
Alex Wong & Stephen “Twitch” Boss
Is there even a contest here? Listen, Scars and Fallin are both great routines and well performed, but Outta Your Mind wasn’t just a great routine it was a game changing routine. If Alex hadn’t been hurt the next week, he would have rode that routine right into the final four. In fact it was such a universally adored routine it alone is causing people to demand Alex be an All-Star this season. One of my top routines ever on the show. While most of my favorite routines make me cry, this one just makes me smile from ear to ear and reminds you that dance can be FUN.
Lauren Froderman & Ade Obayomi
Lauren Froderman & Billy Bell
Neil Haskell & Charlie Bruce (Winner of SYTYCD UK)
I adore Mandy Moore, but this, for me, is the weakest group of the bunch. The Neil/Charlie routine is gorgeous. And Oh Yeah is sexy and well performed. I just loved Boogie Shoes though. It was cute and fun and Lauren and Billy genuinely love each other (just read their tweets back and forth – adorable!). Their friends forever-esque chemistry came out in this routine. So, it’s my pick. Plus I want those bedazzled Chuck Taylors.
My choice to win, come September? As if you need to ask…. Travis friggin Wall, of course. I will say, NappyTabs are a strong second for Outta My Mind. But I just can’t get over how amazing Travis has been and he has only been doing this professionally a few years. We are in season 8 and his first routine for the show was in Season 5. Each one of his are a winner, and he earned this Emmy nomination and he has more than earned to take home that golden statue.
Now the real question…. which dances from this year will we be talking about NEXT summer?
Written by Melissa Miller. Find her on Twitter @serrae
Read Small Screen Scoop Daily for all your So You Think You Can Dance Season 8 Goodies. Or in this case, Season 7, but you get the idea.