Pia Toscano wowed us in the top 12 last night.

Last night on American Idol 2011 Pia Toscano performed a song from the year she was born. It was Whitney Houstons’ “Where Do Broken Hearts Go?”

What did the judges think?

Steven Tyler -Said said she nailed it and she was the reason they called the show American Idol.

Jennifer Lopez – She was glad it wasn’t a ballad, and it was uptempo.

Randy Jackson – Said she’s in the competition to win it, so the other singers better recognize this and up their respective games.

What did you guys think? It seemed maybe a little too ballard-y for her not-a-ballard song! Still, a strong voice that’s not pitchy (backed by someone with some personality) can definitely win this competition. Do you want Toscano to win?

Visit Small Screen Scoop and we can cheer Pie Toscano on together.