In our Glee “Duets” review, we noted that Sam & Quinn’s performance wasn’t our favorite. (They didn’t deserve those breadsticks!) But what about you? We’re going to remind of you each duet performed last night (whether in the competition, or not) and let you vote for your favorite so we can all see what the fans think. First up is our winning pair.

Pair: Sam and Quinn
Song: “Lucky”
Youtube: Video Link
Points in their favor: These characters have an attraction to each other.
Gimmick: Quinn holds the guitar strings as Sam plays.

Pair: Rachel and Finn
Song: “Don’t Go Breaking My Heart”
Youtube: Video Link
Points in their favor: Lea Michele’s voice, the subtext, being a cute couple.
Gimmick: They realize they’re too good and will win the competition and must pick another song.

Pair: Mercedes and Santana
Song: “River Deep, Mountain High”
Youtube: Video Link
Points in their favor: Their voices compliment each other, and they have the powerful woman thing down pat.
Gimmick: It’s unusual to see these two together.

Pair: Kurt & Kurt
Song: “Le Jazz Hot”
Youtube: Video Link
Points in his favor: His voice, song choice, the costuming, and his bravery.
Gimmick: Do we have to say it?

Pair: Mike and Tina
Song: “Sing”
Youtube: Video Link
Points in their favor: It was entertaining, comical and cute.
Gimmick: Mike couldn’t sing.

Pair: Rachel and Kurt
Song: “Happy Days Are Here Again/Come on Get Happy”
Youtube: Video Link
Points in their favor: They have two of the best voices, and this was sans gimmicks – it was just pure voices and emotion.
Gimmick: None.